How to Keep Your HR Budget From Being Cut

It's all about productivity! Become an "HR Hero"

HR needs to recognize (if it doesn't already) that during tight times the CFO and managers alike all want one basic thing. And that thing is… increased productivity which they define as results or outputs per dollar spent.  Incidentally they don't particularly care how it's done, as long as it is done. Unfortunately, instead of being a "productivity consulting department" with answers on how to improve it, most HR department's hardly know what it is no less measure employee productivity. Business is simple; CFO's and managers care about improved productivity, product quality, customer satisfaction, margins, sales or product development speed. Everything else is, relatively speaking, just "chopped liver".

Right now HR departments need to focus on productivity.  Great ones first identify which people programs (training, compensation, recruiting or employee relations) can dramatically increase employee productivity. Then they focus their time and resources on those productivity increasing services and programs. So if you haven't already done it, begin tracking your firm's revenue per employee, profit per employee or employee output per dollar spent.  Next, do a competitive analysis by comparing your figures to your product competitors and to your own "last month's" performance. Then, begin "merciless criticism" of your current approach in order to improve your results everyday until they are the highest in the industry.

Remember, if you can prove that HR increases productivity, product quality, customer satisfaction, margins, sales or product development speed… I guarantee you will be an "HR hero!"

What Steps do you take so they won't cut HR?

The language of business – In order to understand the reasons why they cut HR first you must understand CFO's. Most CFO's are business school graduates. They are trained to use the language of business, which includes dollars, results and numbers.  In contrast, most HR departments tend to focus on process, transactions and "running programs". They talk of employee satisfaction, employee growth and work life balance instead of ROI, metrics or business impact. Programs like O. D. and training are almost always the first to go because they tend to be the weakest in HR in making their own business case.

 Action item


Immediately begin a quick and dirty metrics program.  Make rough calculations on program impacts and ROI (return on investment). Train your HR managers to talk and think in numbers and dollars. Do your own assessment of HR program effectiveness and drop or improve those programs with low impact or ROI.

Seek executive sponsorship – Even when a company's growth is slowing there are divisions and products that are invariably still in growth mode. HR has a bad habit of treating all divisions and managers the same. During tough times it's even more important to focus on powerful managers.  Now be aware, that although most managers "like" their HR people, what HR is seeking here goes beyond liking. First we need to get the buy-in and sponsorship of "powerful managers. Next we need to identify their needs and make your "business case" to these powerful people on how HR can make an impact in the important areas of recruiting and retaining top talent as well as increasing their overall productivity.


Action item
Identify the business units and products that are in a growth mode.  Next identify the key leaders in those areas that have power and internal political pull.  Work with their staffs to identify the key business problems within those units.  Return later with brief plans on how HR can act to improve their business results (time to market, productivity, margins) through people programs that increase retention, productivity and the recruitment of top performers. Shift HR resources into these programs and don't forget to use metrics to measure their impact.  If you succeed in impacting business results, ask the senior leadership to intervene on your behalf with the CFO. If necessary, ask the business unit manager to fund their people programs directly out of their own business unit budget.

Prioritize your programs and services – HR departments tend to operate as a series of independent "silos" with the philosophy that "all programs are important".  Great HR departments work as a unit to focus resources on the most important areas. In addition, great HR strategies are not stagnant.  Instead they shift our focus as the economy changes.  Obviously during times of slow growth, most recruiting and retention efforts can be slowed down, while other programs like productivity, performance management, layoffs and firing bottom performers need to be ramped up.


Action item

HR needs to prioritize its programs and shift its best talent and resources into areas that will have a more immediate return.  This means before the CFO does it, HR needs to shift its internal budget and transfer the best HR professionals into these new focus areas.  In addition, growth departments need to receive prioritized service from HR.  Problems from these divisions must be handled first, and by our best people.  Low growth and low margin divisions need to come last

Improve response time and customer service – We all know that the last few years have been hectic in HR due to expansive growth and as a result it is not unusual for HR responsiveness and customer service to have suffered a little during that period. During tight budget times it can be deadly to be known as an "unresponsive overhead unit". Bad service and frustrated senior managers are likely to "vote with" the CFO when it comes time to cut budgets.



Action item

Conduct a "quick and dirty" satisfaction survey among a sample of your managers in order to identify where you stand.  Avoid the temptation to make it anonymous because that prohibits you from identifying who "dislikes you". Internally within HR begin tracking response times.  For every 10th call or request, track the time it takes to get back to customers.  Survey several of your "users" each week with a paper or e-mail survey to see what they like and dislike about your service. Track the over-all customer service rate and distribute the metrics among your HR staff (if you can afford it offer a reward for great service).

Become a competitive advantage – Most HR programs are "vanilla" and differ little from those at your direct competitors. During tough times executives become increasingly competitive (they're almost always more competitive than HR people). If HR is to survive budget cuts it must demonstrate that its programs and approach provide the company with a distinct competitive advantage in the marketplace.  This means HR professionals must be able to demonstrate that "the way we do it" is different enough and our results are superior enough so that our HR programs need to be maintained or even strengthened.

In a fast changing competitive world, "speed doesn't kill", slow kills! Because the speed of change matters HR must learn to "match" the speed in which their own company's products must improve.  This means that HR must continually improve its speed of change and "obsolete" it's own HR programs at least as fast as the speed the company improves it's own products and at a rate that is even faster than the competitors.



Action item

HR needs to do competitive intelligence and benchmarking against our direct product competitors.  HR must prepare a competitive analysis showing how and where our HR programs are superior. More importantly, demonstrate how HR helped us maintain an advantage in sales, productivity or product development. This means gathering comparison information by talking to "recent hires" from our competitors and even hiring consultants that have worked with our competitors. If it turns out that we are not superior to our competitors then plans must be made to upgrade the services and programs that have the most impact on business results.

Redeploy the talent – Some would argue that CFO's are not "human" (and don't like people) and that's why they cut HR.  In fact, most CFO's do realize the value of top performers in key positions but they do view the average performer as a "cost".  Effective HR departments already know how to do layoffs and to "cut costs". But in addition, HR needs to learn how to rapidly redeploy talent. Redeployment means rapidly moving the most productive workers out of low return divisions and jobs and into higher return ones.  The shifting of great people into the "right job" can have a dramatic increase in productivity and without the need for any additional hiring.



Action item

HR needs to begin a redeployment program. This means a proactive effort to identify top performers that would have an increased impact if they were moved to higher growth divisions or more impactful jobs. Unfortunately most internal people movement programs rely on the employee to volunteer to move.  Under redeployment, HR identifies this talent and proactively persuades them to move (or just moves them) into jobs where they can have a larger impact.  Conversely, low performers in key divisions and jobs must be transferred to where they might make the most productivity impact or should be moved out of the company


The CFO from a Fortune 500 firm that I once worked for told me at our first meeting that he "hated" HR people. When I asked him why he said it was because they always used a term he hated, "strategic investment".  "Strategic investment", to him, meant "putting a lot of money in up front and maybe getting a little return a long time later".  He later added that he also loved to cut the HR budget first because no matter how much you cut it…they still managed to "suck it in" and find a way to maintain all of their existing services.

If there is a lesson to be learned here it is that if HR is to avoid budget cuts it needs to do a preemptive strike.  This means building a relationship with the CFO's office early on in order to identify the criteria that the CFO will use (or did use) for cutting programs.  When these decision criteria are identified, HR needs to shift into immediate action in order to improve their "ratings" on these criteria.  Because when you do, you can then sit back and relax while the CFO cuts their "other favorites: travel, purchasing and the IT department!

About Dr John Sullivan

Dr John Sullivan is an internationally known HR thought-leader from the Silicon Valley who specializes in providing bold and high business impact; strategic Talent Management solutions to large corporations.

Check Also

Peer Interviews – A Powerful “Must Try” Hiring Tool (For improving your assessment and candidate selling results overnight)

It’s the most powerful hiring tool because of its double impact on candidate assessment and …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *